| | | Utica won the toss and will receive |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica30 | FISHER ball on FISHER30. |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 48 yards to the UTICA22, R. Alexander return 17 yards to the UTICA39 (T.Wallace;Artie Bigsby). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica39 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tim Millerick for 12 yards to the FISHER49, 1ST DOWN UTICA, out-of-bounds (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher49 | Zach Jones rush for 4 yards to the FISHER45 (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Fisher45 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 8 yards to the UTICA47 (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 3-14 | at Utica47 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason. |
| Utica | 4-14 | at Utica47 | Casey McNulty punt 32 yards to the FISHER21, Dan Witkowski return 2 yards to the FISHER23 (Peter Vano). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher23 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 12:55. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher23 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Scott Biehl. |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Fisher23 | Brad Carlton rush for 1 yard to the FISHER24 (Eric Kahl;Tracy Branch). |
| Fisher | 3-9 | at Fisher24 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Cory Hopkins. |
| Fisher | 4-9 | at Fisher24 | Clint Doll punt 31 yards to the UTICA45, Adam Keller return 3 yards to the UTICA48 (Scott Allis;John Sheridan). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:00 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica48 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 11:55. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica48 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 5 yards to the FISHER47 (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Fisher47 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Cody Elliot (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 3-5 | at Fisher47 | Michael Clark rush for 7 yards to the FISHER40, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Andre Bliss;Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher40 | Michael Clark rush for 2 yards to the FISHER38 (Andy Episcopo;Adam Kinney). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Fisher38 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 11 yards to the FISHER27, 1ST DOWN UTICA (John Sheridan;Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher27 | Zach Jones rush for 5 yards to the FISHER22 (Brenden Moore). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Fisher22 | Zach Jones rush for no gain to the FISHER22 (Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 3-5 | at Fisher22 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Jeremy Meier. |
| Utica | 4-5 | at Fisher22 | Denis Avdic field goal attempt from 39 GOOD, clock 08:12. |
| | | Utica College 3, St. John Fisher 0 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 30 yards, TOP 03:49 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 61 yards to the FISHER9, Adam Burdick return 20 yards to the FISHER29 (Jason Koons;Adam Keller). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher29 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 08:06. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher29 | C. Zemaitis rush for no gain to the FISHER29 (Eric Kahl;Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Fisher29 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Brad Carlton, dropped pass. |
| Fisher | 3-10 | at Fisher29 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Ryan Schmidt. |
| Fisher | 4-10 | at Fisher29 | Clint Doll punt 33 yards to the UTICA38, Adam Keller return 4 yards to the UTICA42 (Adam Burdick). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:51 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica42 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 07:15. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica42 | Zach Jones rush for 11 yards to the FISHER47, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Joel Vickers). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher47 | PENALTY UTICA false start 5 yards to the UTICA48. |
| Utica | 1-15 | at Utica48 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 2 yards to the 50 yardline (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 2-13 | at Utica50 | Andrew Benkwitt rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (Chris Sawyer). |
| Utica | 3-13 | at Utica50 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by John Sheridan at the FISHER29, John Sheridan return -2 yards to the FISHER27 (Cody Elliot). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:07 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher27 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 05:08. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher27 | C. Zemaitis rush for 1 yard to the FISHER28 (Eric Kahl). |
| Fisher | 2-9 | at Fisher28 | Tim Bailey rush for 7 yards to the FISHER35 (C. Walrath;Steve Karboski). |
| Fisher | 3-2 | at Fisher35 | Tim Bailey rush for 7 yards to the FISHER42, 1ST DOWN FISHER. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher42 | C. Zemaitis rush for 4 yards to the FISHER46 (T. Cunningham). |
| Fisher | 2-6 | at Fisher46 | Brad Carlton rush for 9 yards to the UTICA45, fumble by Brad Carlton recovered by UTICA Eric Kahl at UTICA45. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 28 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica45 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 03:21. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica45 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 10 yards to the FISHER45 (Brenden Moore), PENALTY UTICA pass interference 15 yards to the UTICA30, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 1-25 | at Utica30 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Dayne Bennett for 15 yards to the UTICA45 (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica45 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by Dave Vosburgh at the FISHER35, Dave Vosburgh return 7 yards to the FISHER42 (Cody Elliot). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher42 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 02:22. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher42 | C. Zemaitis rush for 12 yards to the UTICA46, 1ST DOWN FISHER (T. Cunningham;Steve Karboski). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica46 | C. Zemaitis rush for 6 yards to the UTICA40 (Travis Ladd). |
| Fisher | 2-4 | at Utica40 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Brad Carlton for 17 yards to the UTICA23, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica23 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Paul Deckard for 4 yards to the UTICA19 (Peter Vano). |
| Fisher | 2-6 | at Utica19 | C. Zemaitis rush for 6 yards to the UTICA13, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Travis Ladd). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica13 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Brad Carlton for 8 yards to the UTICA5 (Kevin Hennion). |
| Fisher | 2-2 | at Utica05 | C. Zemaitis rush for 5 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN FISHER, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:04. |
| | | Cullen Bradley kick attempt good. |
| | | St. John Fisher 7, Utica College 3 |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 57 yards to the UTICA13, R. Alexander return to the UTICA28 (Scott Allis;T.Wallace), PENALTY FISHER offside defense 5 yards to the FISHER25, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 58 yards, TOP 02:22 |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 55 yards to the UTICA20, R. Alexander return 16 yards to the UTICA36 (Caleb Norton;Ramon Andino). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 00:00. |
| | | St. John Fisher 7, Utica College 3 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | Jake Scott rush for no gain to the UTICA36 (Brenden Moore;Byron Rhone). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica36 | Cody Elliot rush for 7 yards to the UTICA43 (Dave Vosburgh). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Utica43 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Josh Wright for 9 yards to the FISHER48, 1ST DOWN UTICA (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher48 | Jake Scott rush for 3 yards to the FISHER45 (Brenden Moore). |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Fisher45 | Jake Scott rush for 8 yards to the FISHER37, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher37 | Jake Scott rush for 4 yards to the FISHER33 (Nick Krajacic;Adam Kinney). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Fisher33 | Zach Jones pass incomplete to Joshua Mason (Dave Vosburgh). |
| Utica | 3-6 | at Fisher33 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 5 yards to the FISHER38 (Chris Sawyer). |
| Utica | 4-11 | at Fisher38 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tyler Malagisi for 18 yards to the FISHER20, fumble forced by Andy Episcopo, fumble by Tyler Malagisi recovered by UTICA Eric Kahl at FISHER24, 1ST DOWN UTICA. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher24 | Zach Jones rush for 4 yards to the FISHER20 (N. Borkowski;Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Fisher20 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 3-6 | at Fisher20 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 7 yards to the FISHER27 (Joel Vickers;Adam Kinney). |
| Utica | 4-13 | at Fisher27 | Denis Avdic field goal attempt from 43 MISSED - wide left, spot at FISHER27, clock 08:57. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 37 yards, TOP 06:03 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher27 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 08:57. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher27 | C. Zemaitis rush for 3 yards to the FISHER30, out-of-bounds (Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 2-7 | at Fisher30 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Brad Carlton, PENALTY FISHER ineligible downfield on pass declined. |
| Fisher | 3-7 | at Fisher30 | Tim Bailey rush for loss of 7 yards to the FISHER23. |
| Fisher | 4-14 | at Fisher23 | Clint Doll punt 25 yards to the FISHER48, fair catch by Adam Keller. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:12 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher48 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 07:45. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher48 | Zach Jones rush for 1 yard to the FISHER47 (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 2-9 | at Fisher47 | Michael Clark rush for 1 yard to the FISHER46 (Brenden Moore). |
| Utica | 3-8 | at Fisher46 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason. |
| Utica | 4-8 | at Fisher46 | Casey McNulty punt 20 yards to the FISHER26, downed, PENALTY FISHER personal foul (Tyler Schier) 13 yards to the FISHER13, 1st and 10, FISHER ball on FISHER13. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:42 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher13 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 06:03. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher13 | C. Zemaitis rush for 7 yards to the FISHER20 (T. Cunningham). |
| Fisher | 2-3 | at Fisher20 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Ryan Schmidt for 10 yards to the FISHER30, 1ST DOWN FISHER, out-of-bounds (Jon White). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher30 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Cory Hopkins, PENALTY FISHER pass interference (Cory Hopkins) 15 yards to the FISHER15, NO PLAY. |
| Fisher | 1-25 | at Fisher15 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Paul Deckard for 2 yards to the FISHER17 (Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 2-23 | at Fisher17 | C. Zemaitis rush for 9 yards to the FISHER26 (Adam Keller). |
| Fisher | 3-14 | at Fisher26 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Brad Carlton. |
| Fisher | 4-14 | at Fisher26 | Clint Doll punt 27 yards to the UTICA47, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:54 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 04:09. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | Zach Jones rush for 8 yards to the FISHER45 (Brenden Moore;Joel Vickers). |
| Utica | 2-2 | at Fisher45 | Jake Scott rush for 4 yards to the FISHER41, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Brenden Moore;Byron Rhone). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher41 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 2 yards to the FISHER39 (Andre Bliss;Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Fisher39 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 5 yards to the FISHER34, out-of-bounds (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Fisher34 | Jake Scott rush for loss of 6 yards to the FISHER40, fumble by Jake Scott recovered by UTICA Jake Scott at FISHER40. |
| Utica | 4-9 | at Fisher40 | Casey McNulty punt 39 yards to the FISHER1, J. Sedelmeyer return -1 yards to the FISHER0, fumble by J. Sedelmeyer recovered by UTICA Jeremy Meier at FISHER0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:27. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 13 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Denis Avdic kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica College 10, St. John Fisher 7 |
| | | Punt goes off the back of Sedelmeyer's feet at the 1, recovered by UC |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 59 yards to the FISHER11, Ryan Schmidt return 24 yards to the FISHER35 (William Pease). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher35 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 01:17. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher35 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Brad Carlton for 9 yards to the FISHER44 (Eric Kahl;Kevin Hennion). |
| Fisher | 2-1 | at Fisher44 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Cory Hopkins, PENALTY FISHER holding (Pete Soehner) 10 yards to the FISHER34, NO PLAY. |
| Fisher | 2-11 | at Fisher34 | Tim Bailey rush for 21 yards to the UTICA45, 1ST DOWN FISHER, out-of-bounds (Peter Vano), PENALTY UTICA personal foul (Peter Vano) 10 yards to the UTICA35, 1ST DOWN FISHER. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica35 | 1st and 10. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica35 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Ryan Schmidt, dropped pass. |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Utica35 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Paul Deckard for 15 yards to the UTICA20, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Kevin Hennion;C. Walrath). |
| | | game clock at 31.8 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica20 | Tim Bailey sacked for loss of 4 yards to the UTICA24 (Steve Karboski). |
| Fisher | 2-14 | at Utica24 | Timeout St. John Fisher, clock 00:25. |
| Fisher | 2-14 | at Utica24 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Cory Hopkins. |
| Fisher | 3-14 | at Utica24 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Dan Witkowski, PENALTY UTICA pass interference (Andrew Benkwitt) 7 yards to the UTICA17, 1ST DOWN FISHER, NO PLAY. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica17 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Ryan Francis. |
| | | Francis catches the ball in the endzone, but is out of bounds |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Utica17 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Dan Witkowski for 17 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN FISHER, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:06. |
| | | Cullen Bradley kick attempt good. |
| | | St. John Fisher 14, Utica College 10 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 65 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 16 yards to the FISHER46, William Northey return 4 yards to the FISHER42, fumble by William Northey recovered by FISHER Artie Bigsby at UTICA42. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica42 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 00:04. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica42 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete. |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Utica42 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Utica42 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:04 |
| | | St. John Fisher 14, Utica College 10 |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Utica42 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, UTICA ball on UTICA30. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:04 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 12 yards to the UTICA42, on-side kick, recovered by UTICA on UTICA42. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica42 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 14:57. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica42 | Joshua Mason rush for loss of 11 yards to the UTICA31, fumble by Joshua Mason recovered by UTICA Joshua Mason at UTICA32 (Joel Vickers). |
| Utica | 2-20 | at Utica32 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by Nick Krajacic at the UTICA31, Nick Krajacic return 4 yards to the UTICA27 (Joshua Mason). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 10 yards, TOP 00:42 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica27 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 14:15. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica27 | Brad Carlton rush for 22 yards to the UTICA5, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Jon White;T. Cunningham). |
| Fisher | 1-G | at Utica05 | Brad Carlton rush for loss of 1 yard to the UTICA6 (Eric Kahl). |
| Fisher | 2-G | at Utica06 | Brad Carlton rush for 6 yards to the UTICA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:19. |
| | | Cullen Bradley kick attempt failed. |
| | | St. John Fisher 20, Utica College 10 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 27 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 53 yards to the UTICA17, R. Alexander return 15 yards to the UTICA32 (Ramon Andino), PENALTY FISHER personal foul 15 yards to the UTICA47, 1st and 10, UTICA ball on UTICA47. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 13:14. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | Zach Jones rush for loss of 5 yards to the UTICA42 (Andre Bliss). |
| Utica | 2-15 | at Utica42 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Cody Elliot (Andre Bliss). |
| Utica | 3-15 | at Utica42 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 10 yards to the UTICA32 (Chris Sawyer). |
| Utica | 4-25 | at Utica32 | Casey McNulty punt 43 yards to the FISHER25, Dan Witkowski return 0 yards to the FISHER25 (Peter Vano). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 15 yards, TOP 01:24 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher25 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 11:50. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher25 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Jeff Same (Sean Dixon), PENALTY FISHER personal foul (Vince Perrone) 14 yards to the FISHER11, NO PLAY. |
| Fisher | 1-24 | at Fisher11 | 2nd and 24. |
| Fisher | 2-24 | at Fisher11 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Ryan Schmidt for 7 yards to the FISHER18 (Travis Ladd). |
| Fisher | 3-17 | at Fisher18 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Anthony Short for 17 yards to the FISHER35, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Denzel Lee;Eric Kahl). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher35 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Cory Hopkins for 5 yards to the FISHER40 (T. Cunningham). |
| Fisher | 2-5 | at Fisher40 | C. Zemaitis rush for 2 yards to the FISHER42 (C. Walrath). |
| Fisher | 3-3 | at Fisher42 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Dan Witkowski for loss of 1 yard to the FISHER41 (Sean Dixon;Travis Ladd). |
| Fisher | 4-4 | at Fisher41 | Clint Doll punt 42 yards to the UTICA17, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 16 yards, TOP 02:36 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica17 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 09:14. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica17 | Michael Clark rush for 4 yards to the UTICA21 (Chris Sawyer). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Utica21 | Michael Clark rush for 1 yard to the UTICA22 (Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 3-5 | at Utica22 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 10 yards to the UTICA32, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Zach Jones for 8 yards to the UTICA40 (Andre Bliss). |
| Utica | 2-2 | at Utica40 | Timeout Utica College, clock 06:37. |
| Utica | 2-2 | at Utica40 | Cody Elliot rush for 5 yards to the UTICA45, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Nick Krajacic). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica45 | Michael Clark pass incomplete to Tyler Malagisi (Byron Rhone). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica45 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 7 yards to the FISHER48 (Andre Bliss). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Fisher48 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 11 yards to the FISHER37, 1ST DOWN UTICA (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher37 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Cody Elliot (Dave Vosburgh). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Fisher37 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 4 yards to the FISHER33 (Mike Leavell), PENALTY UTICA illegal block 10 yards to the FISHER43. |
| Utica | 2-16 | at Fisher43 | 2nd and 16. |
| Utica | 2-16 | at Fisher43 | Andrew Benkwitt rush for 7 yards to the FISHER36 (Byron Rhone). |
| Utica | 3-9 | at Fisher36 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by Andre Bliss at the FISHER23, Andre Bliss return 0 yards to the FISHER23. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 47 yards, TOP 05:42 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher23 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 03:32. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher23 | Brad Carlton rush for 7 yards to the FISHER30 (Sean Dixon;Kevin Hennion). |
| Fisher | 2-3 | at Fisher30 | Brad Carlton rush for 1 yard to the FISHER31 (Jason Koons), PENALTY UTICA offside defense (Kurt Zimmermann) 5 yards to the FISHER35, 1ST DOWN FISHER, NO PLAY. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher35 | Tim Bailey pass incomplete to Dan Witkowski. |
| Fisher | 2-10 | at Fisher35 | Brad Carlton rush for 10 yards to the FISHER45, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher45 | Brad Carlton rush for 2 yards to the FISHER47 (C. Walrath;Kurt Zimmermann). |
| Fisher | 2-8 | at Fisher47 | Brad Carlton rush for 3 yards to the 50 yardline (Peter Vano). |
| Fisher | 3-5 | at Fisher50 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Brad Carlton for 4 yards to the UTICA46 (Travis Ladd). |
| Fisher | 4-1 | at Utica46 | Clint Doll punt 26 yards to the UTICA20, Adam Keller return 0 yards to the UTICA20 (Adam Burdick). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 31 yards, TOP 03:08 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica20 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 00:24. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica20 | Zach Jones rush for 2 yards to the UTICA22 (Andy Episcopo;Chris Sawyer). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 2 yards, TOP 03:03 |
| | | St. John Fisher 20, Utica College 10 |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Utica22 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Utica22 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tyler Malagisi for 7 yards to the UTICA29 (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 3-1 | at Utica29 | Jake Scott rush for 1 yard to the UTICA30, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Andy Episcopo;Brenden Moore). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica30 | PENALTY UTICA false start (Tyler Malagisi) 5 yards to the UTICA25. |
| Utica | 1-15 | at Utica25 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 4 yards to the UTICA21 (Chris Sawyer;Adam Kinney). |
| Utica | 2-19 | at Utica21 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Jeremy Meier (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 3-19 | at Utica21 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason. |
| Utica | 4-19 | at Utica21 | Casey McNulty punt 37 yards to the FISHER42, Adam Burdick return 1 yards to the FISHER43, fumble forced by Peter Vano, fumble by Adam Burdick recovered by UTICA Adam Keller at FISHER43. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 1 yards, TOP 03:03 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher43 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 12:21. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher43 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tyler Malagisi for 13 yards to the FISHER30, fumble by Tyler Malagisi recovered by FISHER John Sheridan at FISHER33. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher33 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 12:11. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher33 | C. Zemaitis rush for 12 yards to the FISHER45, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Kevin Hennion). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher45 | C. Zemaitis rush for 11 yards to the UTICA44, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Kevin Hennion;T. Cunningham). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica44 | Tim Bailey rush for 6 yards to the UTICA38 (Peter Vano). |
| Fisher | 2-4 | at Utica38 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Paul Deckard for 24 yards to the UTICA14, 1ST DOWN FISHER, out-of-bounds (Peter Vano). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica14 | C. Zemaitis rush for loss of 1 yard to the UTICA15 (Travis Ladd;C. Walrath). |
| Fisher | 2-11 | at Utica15 | Tim Bailey rush for 14 yards to the UTICA1, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Travis Ladd). |
| Fisher | 1-G | at Utica01 | C. Zemaitis rush for 1 yard to the UTICA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:44. |
| | | Cullen Bradley kick attempt good. |
| | | St. John Fisher 27, Utica College 10 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 67 yards, TOP 02:33 |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 55 yards to the UTICA15, R. Alexander return 21 yards to the UTICA36 (J. Sedelmeyer). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 09:38. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 2 yards to the UTICA38 (Andre Bliss). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Utica38 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 5 yards to the UTICA43, out-of-bounds (Andre Bliss). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Utica43 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 5 yards to the UTICA48, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica48 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 11 yards to the FISHER41, 1ST DOWN UTICA (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher41 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Cody Elliot for 6 yards to the FISHER35 (Chris Sawyer). |
| Utica | 2-4 | at Fisher35 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 5 yards to the FISHER30, 1ST DOWN UTICA (John Sheridan;Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher30 | Timeout St. John Fisher, clock 08:01. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher30 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Cody Elliot. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Fisher30 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Cody Elliot (Brenden Moore). |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Fisher30 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 20 yards to the FISHER10, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Ramon Andino;Dave Vosburgh). |
| Utica | 1-G | at Fisher10 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Keith Barone for loss of 1 yard to the FISHER11 (Brenden Moore). |
| Utica | 2-G | at Fisher11 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 11 yards to the FISHER0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:45. |
| | | Meier makes a great one-handed grab and gets a foot down for the TD |
| | | Denis Avdic kick attempt good. |
| | | St. John Fisher 27, Utica College 17 |
| Utica | 1-G | at Utica30 | PENALTY FISHER offside defense 5 yards to the UTICA35. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 64 yards, TOP 02:58 |
| | | Denis Avdic kickoff 15 yards to the 50 yardline, on-side kick (touch by receiving team), recovered by UTICA on FISHER45. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher45 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 06:40. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Fisher45 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Fisher45 | Andrew Benkwitt rush for 1 yard to the FISHER44 (Joel Vickers). |
| Utica | 3-9 | at Fisher44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Dayne Bennett for 7 yards to the FISHER37 (Andy Episcopo). |
| Utica | 4-2 | at Fisher37 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Cody Elliot (Mike Benderski). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher37 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 05:44. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher37 | C. Zemaitis rush for 4 yards to the FISHER41 (Steve Karboski;Eric Kahl). |
| Fisher | 2-6 | at Fisher41 | C. Zemaitis rush for 8 yards to the FISHER49, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Eric Kahl). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Fisher49 | PENALTY FISHER false start (C. Balcerzak) 5 yards to the FISHER44. |
| Fisher | 1-15 | at Fisher44 | Tim Bailey sacked for loss of 1 yard to the FISHER43 (Denzel Lee). |
| Fisher | 2-16 | at Fisher43 | Timeout St. John Fisher, clock 03:30. |
| Fisher | 2-16 | at Fisher43 | Tim Bailey rush for 2 yards to the FISHER45. |
| Fisher | 3-14 | at Fisher45 | Timeout Utica College, clock 03:13. |
| Fisher | 3-14 | at Fisher45 | Tim Bailey pass complete to Scott Biehl for 25 yards to the UTICA30, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Jon White). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica30 | C. Zemaitis rush for 14 yards to the UTICA16, 1ST DOWN FISHER (T. Cunningham). |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica16 | C. Zemaitis rush for 3 yards to the UTICA13 (Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 2-7 | at Utica13 | C. Zemaitis rush for 9 yards to the UTICA4, 1ST DOWN FISHER (Sean Dixon). |
| Fisher | 1-G | at Utica04 | C. Zemaitis rush for 4 yards to the UTICA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:50. |
| | | Cullen Bradley kick attempt good. |
| | | St. John Fisher 34, Utica College 17 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 63 yards, TOP 05:44 |
| | | Cullen Bradley kickoff 55 yards to the UTICA15, R. Alexander return 15 yards to the UTICA30 (Artie Bigsby;T.Wallace). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica30 | Clock 00:40. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica30 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 7 yards to the UTICA23 (Joel Vickers). |
| Utica | 2-17 | at Utica23 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 10 yards to the UTICA33 (John Sheridan). |
| Utica | 3-7 | at Utica33 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Jeremy Meier. |
| Utica | 4-7 | at Utica33 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jake Scott for 13 yards to the UTICA46, 1ST DOWN UTICA, out-of-bounds (Brenden Moore;Artie Bigsby). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica46 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by John Sheridan at the FISHER10, John Sheridan return 53 yards to the UTICA37, out-of-bounds (Jake Scott). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:50 |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica37 | ST. JOHN FISHER drive start at 00:00. |
| Fisher | 1-10 | at Utica37 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | St. John Fisher 34, Utica College 17 |